Table 1

Study characteristics of the 19 primary studies included in this systematic review

StudyCountryPatient inclusion criteriaAnterior/
posterior circulation
Number of casesSource images and CFD model setupHaemodynamic parameters in CFD model
Correlations with anatomical characteristics of the sICAS lesions in cross-sectional and longitudinal studies
Nam et al 15 China50%–99% sICASAnterior circulation56CTA-based generic steady modelPR, SSR ratio, velocity ratio
Liu et al 11 China70%–99% sICASAnterior and posterior circulations11CTA-based patient-specific transient modelPR
Zhang et al 16 China50%–99% sICASAnterior circulation40TOF-MRA-based generic transient modelPR, WSSR
Lan et al 13 China50%–99% sICASAnterior and posterior circulations39CTA-based generic steady modelrWSS measures
Correlations with collateral and perfusion status in cross-sectional studies
Leng et al 17 China50%–99% sICASAnterior circulation85CTA-based generic steady modelPressure gradient
Lan et al 18 China50%–99% sICASAnterior circulation83CTA-based generic steady modelPR
Wang et al 19 China30%–99% sICASAnterior and posterior circulations18Biplane DSA-based patient-specific steady modelPR
Raynald et al 12 China50%–70% sICASAnterior and posterior circulations20CTA-based patient-specific transient modelPressure, velocity
Yin et al
10
China50%–99% sICASAnterior and posterior circulations10CTA-based generic transient modelPR
Correlations with stroke mechanisms in cross-sectional studies
Feng et al 21 China50%–99% sICASAnterior circulation99CTA-based generic steady modelPR, WSSR
Li et al 22 China50%–99% sICASAnterior circulation84CTA-based generic steady modelPR
Correlations with cerebral small vessel disease in cross-sectional study
Zheng et al 24 China50%–99% sICASAnterior circulation112CTA-based generic steady modelPR, WSSR
Correlations with the risk of stroke recurrence in medically treated patients with sICAS
Leng et al 14 China70%–99% sICASAnterior and posterior circulations32CTA-based generic steady modelPR, SSR ratio, velocity ratio
Leng et al 7 China50%–99% sICASAnterior and posterior circulations245CTA-based generic steady modelPR, WSSR
Tian et al 25 China50%–99% sICASAnterior and posterior circulations245CTA-based generic steady modelPR, WSSR
Feng et al 26 China50%–99% sICASAnterior and posterior circulations157CTA-based generic steady modelPR
Correlations with functional outcome in patients with sICAS receiving acute reperfusion therapy
Wu et al 27 ChinaPatients receiving intravenous thrombolysis or acute endovascular treatment with 50%–99% sICASAnterior circulation120TOF-MRA-based patient-specific steady modelPR, WSSR
Changes of the haemodynamic parameters in sICAS with stenting treatment
Zhang et al 28 China70%–99% sICASAnterior circulation513DRA-based generic transient modelPressure, velocity, vorticity, WSS
Zhou et al 29 China70%–99% sICASPosterior circulation623DRA-based generic transient modelPressure, velocity, vorticity, WSS
  • CFD, computational fluid dynamics; CTA, CT angiography; 3DRA, three-dimensional rotational angiography; DSA, digital subtraction angiography; PR, pressure ratio; rWSS, relative wall shear stress; sICAS, symptomatic intracranial atherosclerotic stenosis; SSR, shear strain rate; TOF-MRA, time-of-flight MR angiography; WSSR, wall shear stress ratio.