Study characteristics of the 19 primary studies included in this systematic review
Study | Country | Patient inclusion criteria | Anterior/ posterior circulation | Number of cases | Source images and CFD model setup | Haemodynamic parameters in CFD model |
Correlations with anatomical characteristics of the sICAS lesions in cross-sectional and longitudinal studies | ||||||
Nam et al 15 | China | 50%–99% sICAS | Anterior circulation | 56 | CTA-based generic steady model | PR, SSR ratio, velocity ratio |
Liu et al 11 | China | 70%–99% sICAS | Anterior and posterior circulations | 11 | CTA-based patient-specific transient model | PR |
Zhang et al 16 | China | 50%–99% sICAS | Anterior circulation | 40 | TOF-MRA-based generic transient model | PR, WSSR |
Lan et al 13 | China | 50%–99% sICAS | Anterior and posterior circulations | 39 | CTA-based generic steady model | rWSS measures |
Correlations with collateral and perfusion status in cross-sectional studies | ||||||
Leng et al 17 | China | 50%–99% sICAS | Anterior circulation | 85 | CTA-based generic steady model | Pressure gradient |
Lan et al 18 | China | 50%–99% sICAS | Anterior circulation | 83 | CTA-based generic steady model | PR |
Wang et al 19 | China | 30%–99% sICAS | Anterior and posterior circulations | 18 | Biplane DSA-based patient-specific steady model | PR |
Raynald et al 12 | China | 50%–70% sICAS | Anterior and posterior circulations | 20 | CTA-based patient-specific transient model | Pressure, velocity |
Yin et al
10 | China | 50%–99% sICAS | Anterior and posterior circulations | 10 | CTA-based generic transient model | PR |
Correlations with stroke mechanisms in cross-sectional studies | ||||||
Feng et al 21 | China | 50%–99% sICAS | Anterior circulation | 99 | CTA-based generic steady model | PR, WSSR |
Li et al 22 | China | 50%–99% sICAS | Anterior circulation | 84 | CTA-based generic steady model | PR |
Correlations with cerebral small vessel disease in cross-sectional study | ||||||
Zheng et al 24 | China | 50%–99% sICAS | Anterior circulation | 112 | CTA-based generic steady model | PR, WSSR |
Correlations with the risk of stroke recurrence in medically treated patients with sICAS | ||||||
Leng et al 14 | China | 70%–99% sICAS | Anterior and posterior circulations | 32 | CTA-based generic steady model | PR, SSR ratio, velocity ratio |
Leng et al 7 | China | 50%–99% sICAS | Anterior and posterior circulations | 245 | CTA-based generic steady model | PR, WSSR |
Tian et al 25 | China | 50%–99% sICAS | Anterior and posterior circulations | 245 | CTA-based generic steady model | PR, WSSR |
Feng et al 26 | China | 50%–99% sICAS | Anterior and posterior circulations | 157 | CTA-based generic steady model | PR |
Correlations with functional outcome in patients with sICAS receiving acute reperfusion therapy | ||||||
Wu et al 27 | China | Patients receiving intravenous thrombolysis or acute endovascular treatment with 50%–99% sICAS | Anterior circulation | 120 | TOF-MRA-based patient-specific steady model | PR, WSSR |
Changes of the haemodynamic parameters in sICAS with stenting treatment | ||||||
Zhang et al 28 | China | 70%–99% sICAS | Anterior circulation | 51 | 3DRA-based generic transient model | Pressure, velocity, vorticity, WSS |
Zhou et al 29 | China | 70%–99% sICAS | Posterior circulation | 62 | 3DRA-based generic transient model | Pressure, velocity, vorticity, WSS |
CFD, computational fluid dynamics; CTA, CT angiography; 3DRA, three-dimensional rotational angiography; DSA, digital subtraction angiography; PR, pressure ratio; rWSS, relative wall shear stress; sICAS, symptomatic intracranial atherosclerotic stenosis; SSR, shear strain rate; TOF-MRA, time-of-flight MR angiography; WSSR, wall shear stress ratio.